Some preserved sites.
Some history and culture
Controversies Concerning Archaeology
American Indian Voices
News Archive Index
Return to main Learn page
Please inform the webmaster of any broken links!
Octagon mound needs to be made a public site
Posted to the Friends of the AIM support group
"If this is private land and its value as a golf course outweighs its value as
a sacred site and an archaeological marvel, that needs to change."
The verdict is in: The court found Barbara Crandell guilty of criminal
Her crime? She went to the Octagon mound to pray. She has done that repeatedly
over 20 years. I attended monthly meetings of the Friends of the Mounds over
the last two years in which she reported doing so. Executives from the Ohio
Historical Society, which owns the site, also attended. Not once did they tell
her to stop going there to pray.
Why did she go to the Octagon when there are so many other places to go? Why
not go to a church? Barbara is Cherokee. She believes the people
archaeologists call "Hopewell" were the Cherokee. She believes her ancestors
prayed at the Octagon and were buried there. Archaeologists disagree, but
archaeologists have doubts about the religious assertions of most groups,
including Christians. And most archaeologists agree that this was a sacred
site built by ancestors of Native Americans.
But, of course, the site is also a golf course. Our county has many golf
courses, but this is the only one built upon a site considered sacred, and
this is the only one that is private.
Moundbuilders Country Club has a lease on the land. Barbara's verdict was
based on the assertion that the club's lease makes this a private site. Never
mind its archaeological or spiritual significance, or Barbara's right to
religious freedom. Apparently, a lease trumps all that. Barbara Crandell has
no right to go there to pray; members have the right to go there to play golf.
The verdict is in, and something is wrong.
The Octagon ought to be cherished for both its sacred character and its
archaeological importance -- and ought to be public. Barbara's attorney wanted
to argue these points. He wanted to introduce documents such as the deed and
the lease, both of which address the public nature of the site. He wanted to
call witnesses to testify to its religious and archaeological significance. He
wanted to invoke religious freedom.
He was forbidden to present those documents, call those witnesses or make
those arguments in the trial. The prosecutor told the jury that this is
private land, and Barbara was interfering with members of a private club.
If this is private land and its value as a golf course outweighs its value as
a sacred site and an archaeological marvel, that needs to change.
The site is too important to be private. These are not just any mounds. That
statement is true even apart from its sacred character, on archaeological
grounds. An international team of archaeologists led by Christopher Scarre of
Cambridge University in England has included Newark's Octagon Earthworks on a
list of 70 wonders of the ancient world. Only three sites in all of North
America made the list. The other two, of course, are public.
The Octagon is considered world-class by archaeologists and sacred by Native
Americans. Nothing else in all of Central Ohio is nearly so significant.
We have hidden it under a bushel or, rather, a golf course. That needs to
change. The Octagon needs to become a public site where families can picnic,
classes of school children can come routinely, Native Americans can celebrate
their heritage, visitors from Ohio and other states and nations can visit, and
anyone who wants to pray, can do so.
Dr. Richard Shiels is a professor of history at the Newark Campus of The Ohio
State University/Central Ohio Technical College.
Advocate reader columnist
Originally published Wednesday, November 13, 2002
Go to News Archive Index